Can India tax an Irish company when it sells a foreign company that owns an Indian subsidiary? In FireEye Ireland Limited v. ACIT [IT(IT)A No. 1431/Del/2025], pronounced on 30 September 2026, the Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ("ITAT") held that it cannot, at least under the India-Ireland tax treaty.
Under the Income-tax Act, 1961 ("the Act"), the answer would ordinarily be yes. Explanation 5 to section 9(1)(i) deems shares of a foreign company to be situated in India if they derive their value substantially from Indian assets. A sale of those shares between two non-residents can therefore be taxed in India as an indirect transfer.
The Act is not the end of the enquiry, though. Where the seller is resident in a treaty country, the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement ("DTAA") decides whether India may exercise that taxing right. Several of India's treaties confine source taxation of share gains to shares "in a company which is a resident of a Contracting State". Any other alienation falls into a residuary clause that taxes the gain only where the seller resides.
FireEye tests how far a domestic deeming provision can reach once a treaty with this kind of wording applies.
FireEye Ireland Limited ("FIL") is an Irish tax resident and part of the FireEye Group. It held a tax residency certificate of Ireland, had been in business since 2013, employed more than 150 people, and had no permanent establishment in India.
Under a Share Purchase Agreement dated 23 July 2021, FIL sold its holdings in seventeen group entities to Mandiant Ireland Limited ("MIL"), another Irish group company, as part of an internal restructuring. One of the companies that was being sold was FireEye International LLC ("FE LLC"), a US company that held Mandiant Cybersecurity Private Limited ("MCPL"), an Indian company.
FIL disclosed the gain on FE LLC in its Indian return for AY 2022-23. It claimed the gain was taxable only in Ireland under Article 13(6) of the DTAA, where it was also exempt as an intra-group transfer.
The Assessing Officer disagreed, and the Dispute Resolution Panel upheld that view. The Assessing Officer treated the sale as an indirect transfer of MCPL's shares under Explanation 5 to section 9(1)(i), brought it within Article 13(5) of the DTAA, and added about INR 497.7 crore as capital gains in India. He also invoked Article 6(1) of the Multilateral Instrument ("MLI"), arguing that treaty relief should be denied because it led to double non-taxation.
With a separate addition on software receipts, the assessed income rose to about INR 562.9 crore, against returned income of about INR 13.1 crore.
The core issue was whether a domestic deeming fiction could recharacterize, for treaty purposes, the sale of a US company as a sale of shares in an Indian company.
The Revenue's route ran through Article 3(2) of the DTAA. Article 3(2) allows an undefined treaty term to take its domestic-law meaning. On that basis, the Revenue read "alienation" in Article 13(5) as "transfer" under section 2(47) of the Act, which would bring the indirect transfer of MCPL within Article 3(2).
FIL's answer was rooted in what was actually sold. The asset alienated was its interest in FE LLC, a US company. Article 13(5) covers only shares of a company resident in India or Ireland, so the gain fell outside it and into the residuary Article 13(6). FIL also relied on the established principle that a domestic deeming fiction cannot be read into a treaty without corresponding treaty language.
The Tribunal deleted the capital gains addition, on the below four strands of reasoning.
The Tribunal worked through each paragraph of Article 13. Paragraphs 1 to 4 deal with immovable property, movable property forming part of the business property of a permanent establishment, ships and aircraft, and alienation of shares of the capital stock of a company the property of which consists directly or indirectly principally of immovable property, and none applied.
Whereas, Article 13(5) allows source taxation of gains on alienation of shares only in a company resident in a Contracting State. FE LLC was a US company, resident in neither India nor Ireland. The gain therefore fell under Article 13(6), which taxes it only in the seller's state of residence, which is Ireland.
Because the treaty language was clear, the Tribunal held that no question of interpreting "alienation" even arose.
The Tribunal held that a tax treaty is an agreement between two states, not a taxing statute. Its terms carry their ordinary meaning in context and in light of the treaty's purpose.
Section 2(47) is a deliberately wide, inclusive definition. Importing it into Article 13 through Article 3(2) would let domestic law expand the treaty's reach unilaterally. Article 3(2) is a tool for resolving genuine ambiguity, not for creating it. The Tribunal relied on the Delhi High Court in CIT (International Taxation) v. Telstra Singapore Pte. Ltd. [2024] 165 taxmann.com 85 (Delhi), which held that unilateral domestic amendments cannot override treaty provisions.
Explanation 5 to section 9(1)(i) operates within the Act. Without matching treaty wording, it cannot be read into the DTAA to create a taxing right the treaty does not give.
The Tribunal drew on the Mumbai ITAT in Sofina S.A. v. ACIT [2020] 116 taxmann.com 706 (Mumbai - Trib.) on a similarly worded India-Belgium treaty. It also relied on Sanofi Pasteur Holding SA (Andhra Pradesh HC) and on DIT v. New Skies Satellite BV (Delhi HC), affirmed by the Supreme Court in Engineering Analysis. The common thread of these rulings is that a change in domestic law, whether retrospective or prospective, does not change a treaty.
On the MLI argument, the Tribunal found no evidence of abuse. The Revenue had made no specific enquiry and had relied only on an interpretation that favoured it.
FIL had operated since 2013 with real business and staff. The agreement covered seventeen entities as part of a global restructuring. The Tribunal held it too narrow of a view to say the restructuring was carried out only to move the Indian company.
FireEye is a ruling on the wording of one treaty. Its value lies in the method, not a blanket rule that offshore sales are safe.
Read the capital gains article first - Treaties where Article 13(5) is limited to shares of a company resident in a Contracting State, with a residuary clause in favour of the residence state, may protect a sale one level above the Indian company. Treaties with broader language, such as "directly or indirectly" or a specific rule for shares deriving value from immovable property, may not.
Substance still matters - FIL succeeded on abuse because it had real operations and a genuine group-wide restructuring. A holding company with little substance, or a transaction built around the Indian asset alone, invites a very different MLI or GAAR enquiry.
Mind Tiger Global - The order does not discuss the Supreme Court's ruling in Authority for Advance Rulings v. Tiger Global International II Holdings (2026), where treaty protection was denied on an offshore sale with an underlying Indian asset. That case turned on the India - Mauritius treaty and a finding that the arrangement was designed for a tax advantage. Until a higher forum reconciles the two lines of reasoning, the Revenue may test FireEye on appeal.
Offshore holding structures with an Indian subsidiary should therefore be tested treaty by treaty, looking at the exact article wording, the seller's substance, and the commercial purpose of the deal.
FireEye Ireland reaffirms a basic principle of treaty interpretation. Domestic law decides what India wants to tax, but the treaty decides what India may tax from a treaty protected seller.
Where the treaty allocates a gain to the seller's state of residence, that allocation cannot be undone by reading the Act's definition of "transfer" or its indirect transfer fiction into the treaty. Any departure must come from the treaty's own anti-abuse provisions, supported by facts.
For groups planning reorganizations that involve Indian subsidiaries, the ruling is useful. It is also a reminder that the answer depends on the specific treaty and on the substance behind the structure.