EKGE Retail LLP v. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax & Ors., W.P. No. 21210 of 2022, Telangana High Court (P. Sam Koshy, ACJ and Narsing Rao Nandikonda, J), order dated 13 October 2026, AY 2018-19.
A tax saving can start a GAAR enquiry. It cannot finish one. That is the core of the Telangana High Court's ruling setting aside the GAAR Approving Panel's directions against EKGE Retail LLP, after testing each statutory ingredient of Chapter X-A in turn.
In June 2017, New Meena Bazar International Pvt. Ltd. sold its "Mebaz" apparel business to Vedant Fashions as a going concern for about ₹210.46 crore. The slump sale produced long-term capital gains of about ₹175.92 crore under Section 50B.
After paying liabilities, the company held a surplus of about ₹130 crore that it had no use for. It parked the money in liquid funds, consulted wealth managers at ICICI, HDFC, IIFL, Anand Rathi and Kotak, and engaged an internal consultant. It then settled on an allocation - about one-third to listed equities and two-thirds to bonds and debt funds.
Within the equity allocation, it was advised to buy shares of large listed companies before bonus issues and sell after allotment, on the view that ex-bonus prices tend to settle slightly above the theoretical level. It invested ₹106.31 crore, sold shares worth ₹57.24 crore after the bonus, and kept shares costing ₹49.07 crore. Because bonus shares carry a nil cost under Section 55(2) and sales follow FIFO under CBDT Circular No. 704, the sales produced a short-term capital loss of about ₹49.33 crore. This was set off against the slump-sale gains under Section 70(2).
A search on the group in November 2018 found no incriminating material. Of about 105 group assessments reopened afterwards, 104 closed with nil or minimal additions. EKGE's assessment for AY 2018-19, the first year GAAR applied, was the one left open.
In April 2021 the Assessing Officer asked why GAAR should not apply to the bonus share trades. The matter went from the Principal Commissioner to the Approving Panel under Section 144 BA. On 23 February 2022 the Panel directed that the trades be treated as an impermissible avoidance arrangement. As the Revenue argued it before the Court, the case was that -
Panel directions cannot be appealed under Section 144 BA (14), so EKGE challenged them in a writ petition under Article 226.
The Court set aside the directions and allowed the set-off. It began by setting out the structure of Section 96(1) - a threshold (there must be an "arrangement" under Section 102(1) and two cumulative effects (a main purpose of obtaining a tax benefit, and at least one tainted element in clauses (a) to (d). Because Chapter X-A can disregard or re-characterise transactions, the Court held that its conditions must be read strictly and that the Revenue must prove every ingredient. The Revenue failed on each.
No "arrangement" - The words "transaction, operation, scheme, agreement or understanding" in Section 102(1), read together, imply concert between identifiable parties or a pre-ordained set of steps within the taxpayer's control. Exchange trades at market prices with unknown counterparties have neither. Whether a given trade made or lost money depended on the market, not on any design.
No main purpose of a tax benefit - The statute says "main purpose", not "a purpose" or a side effect. The Panel had reasoned backwards from the result - because a tax benefit arose, it assumed that was the aim. The Court called this reasoning from effect to intention. It also pointed to a commercial record the Panel had largely ignored; the wealth-manager process, the one-third equity allocation, the arbitrage rationale, and the ₹49.07 crore of shares the company kept. A taxpayer whose only object was to manufacture a loss would have had no reason to stay invested.
A set-off is not a "tax benefit" - Income tax is a single annual levy, and total income can only be computed after losses are set off against gains. Section 70(2) is part of that computation, not a concession. A tax benefit under Chapter X-A has to be something secured by subverting the scheme of the Act, not the ordinary working of a computation provision on a loss that was genuinely incurred.
No misuse or abuse; clause (b) - The company applied Section 70(2), the nil-cost rule in Section 55 and the CBDT's FIFO circular exactly as written. Abuse means using a provision for a purpose alien to it; set-off was used for the very purpose it exists.
No abnormal means or manner; clause (d) - Clause (d) looks at how a transaction is done, not at its outcome. Trading listed shares on a SEBI-regulated exchange, with securities transaction tax paid, is the most ordinary way to deal in equities. To call it a means not ordinarily used for bona fide purposes "would be to stand the clause upon its head".
The Court also noted that a clean search and 104 closed group assessments called, at the least, for a careful and reasoned case on each ingredient before invoking Chapter X-A. The directions offered none.
Read with the handful of GAAR rulings so far, EKGE sharpens a line that was already forming; off-market, related-party or circular steps attract GAAR; genuine market trades do not.
EKGE goes further than Anvida Bandi. Anvida turned largely on the absence of evidence. EKGE decides the case at the threshold, holding that open market trades are not an "arrangement" at all, and adds a principle that reaches beyond bonus shares; a set-off allowed by the computation provisions is not, by itself, a "tax benefit".
That second point may matter in cases like Hinduja, where the Revenue's objection is also to losses absorbing gains. The difference is that Hinduja involves a related party restructuring, not anonymous market trades, so the threshold defence in EKGE will not carry over automatically.
The Revenue may well take EKGE to the Supreme Court, and the Hinduja matter will test how far the set-off reasoning travels. For now, the message is clear - tax-efficient does not mean impermissible. In GAAR cases, substance and evidence decide.